Eric Schmidt on Maps situation, the Android-Apple platform fight

By , Oct 11, 2012

Google chairman Eric Schmidt sat down with The Wall Street Journal tech columnists Walt Mossberg and Kara Swisher last night to talk Maps, Apple and Android“Apple should have kept our maps”, he remarked. “Apple decided a long time ago to do their own maps”, he revealed, suggesting Google very well knew way in advance that the iPhone maker would nuke Google Maps from orbit on iOS devices.

He also talks about the epic iOS versus Android fight and comments what it would take to persuade him to become an Apple CEO. A couple more highlights and a nice video right after the break…

And during an interview at the 92nd Street Y in New York last night, he also sarcastically remarked that “Apple’s done very well using our maps”.

Just to refresh your memory, Apple insiders told Bloomberg that Steve Jobs initiated the mapping project and put mobile software chief Forstall in charge. This contradicts another article from The New York Times, which quotes former Apple engineers who claim that Maps was an afterthought when Apple was designing the original iPhone.

Shortly following the iPhone’s introduction in 2007, Apple realized people use Maps a lot on their device, which caused friction between Apple and Google as the former was nervous about the latter collecting the iPhone users’ geographical location and other data each time they used the stock iOS Maps app that used to relied on a Google Maps backend.

Schmidt added fuel to fire by telling Mossberg that “[now they’ve] discovered that maps are really hard”. What he seems to be forgetting is that Apple Maps just launched with turn-by-turn navigation, spoken directions and 3D view, all of which were missing from the initial Google Maps release seven years ago.

It could be argued Apple shouldn’t have launched Maps until it was fully ready for prime time (Tim Cook said as much in his apology), though any fair comparison between the two products would have to wait at least a few years, when Apple works out all the kinks, smooths out the rough edges and improve upon reliability and accuracy of third-party data sets.

Here’s an interesting exchange between Schmidt and Swisher/Mossberg:

Swisher: What argument could you make to Apple to keep your maps?

Schmidt: They’re better maps.

Mossberg: Are you going to make your own iOS map?

Schmidt: Don’t want to pre-announce products, but if we made one, they would have to approve it. … They haven’t approved all of our apps in the past. (Schmidt allows that the two companies are always in communication.)

We know Google’s been working on an iOS maps app since the public announcement of Apple Maps in June. It’s apparently awaiting approval and Schmidt previously warned that the ball is now in Apple’s court.

Google was reportedly shocked as its contract with Apple to keep the maps app on the iPhone “had more time remaining”, but I’d bet my shirt they knew about Apple’s decision way in advance.

You can watch Schmidt’s talk in a video I’ve included below (fast-forward to mark 17:30 for Maps remarks).

Google’s chairman also disses Microsoft, calling them a “well-run company”, which however has yet to bring “state-of-the-art products” to market.

Schmidt also said he’d love to be the CEO of Apple, if presented with such an opportunity, because the iPhone maker “has the most cash”. Doesn’t sound like the answer Apple’s HR department would deem satisfactory.

Maybe Schmidt should see this recruiting video to realize life at Apple is all work, long hours and $1 annual CEO salary.

As for Android, Schmidt says the battle between Apple and Google for smartphone supremacy is “the defining fight in the industry today”, explaining there is a “huge race specifically between Apple and the Android platform for additional features”.

The Android-Apple platform fight is the defining contest. Here’s why: Apple has thousands of developers building for it. Google’s platform, Android, is even larger.

Four times more Android phones than Apple phones. 500 million phones already in use. Doing 1.3 million activations a day. We’ll be at 1 billion mobile devices in a year.

He’s right about the numbers playing into Google’s favor.

But this game is not about the numbers, it’s about the ecosystems, the fact Schmidt is perfectly aware of.

It ain’t about the iPad versus Nexus 7 versus Kindle Fire.

It’s iTunes versus Play Store versus Amazon Store.

Otherwise, Wall Street would be quite impressed by Android’s huge unit numbers and bored with Apple’s “disappointing” iPhone sales.

Let’s not also forget that Schmidt sat on Apple’s board when Apple was developing the iPhone (and Google was also toying with the Android project).

The Loop‘s Jim Dalrymple put it best:

Schmidt steals whatever he can from Apple while sitting on the company’s board and then slithers away like a slug.

No wonder many people buy Steve Jobs’s argument that Android is a stolen product that lifted the look and feel and features from Apple as soon as the company unveiled the handset.

What say you?

Are those douchebag comments or perfectly valid remarks on Schmidt’s part?

  • Share:
  • Follow:
  • VATekMan

    The comment about Apple having the most money, I would guess that it is not in regards to him being able to get paid more but as a company having more money gives you more flexibility for development of hardware and software and the ability to buy up small companies that have a great idea but not the funds to really implement it…

    But that is just my thought and guess on it…

    • @dongiuj

      My thoughts exactly.

    • http://www.facebook.com/karol.ski.92 Karol Ski

      my guess is similar… author of this article is just simple minded…

  • thor_molecules

    Is this article serious? Hopefully this is satire, and iDB wouldn’t be so irresponsible to run this piece of unsubstantiated trash.

    Because, wow.

    • CollegiateLad

      Agreed!

    • http://www.facebook.com/karol.ski.92 Karol Ski

      agreed… this is one bad article….

  • Ignacio Irigoyen

    I rely do not understand Eric Schmidt, they where giving iOS not the full features of maps, and you talk like you are a good guy and Apple idea to move away from your maps is an stupid idea because yours are better?
    They might be better (for now), but you can not give Apple bread crumbs of your software and expect them to take it silently.

    Just my opinion

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1432237131 Chhun Sereyrithy

      I’m with you!

    • Anirudh B

      Google wanted to give the full features of their Maps to Apple in exchange for more branding and Google Latitude, but Apple refused (because they didn’t want Google branding and because they didn’t want competition for “Find My Friends”). Please don’t blame Google for giving “bread crumbs” when Apple refused Google’s terms to get more than bread crumbs.

    • EpicFacepalm

      What did you expect :)

  • VATekMan

    Actually listening to the interview, the comment that “apple should have kept our maps” was said as a joke

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1071132386 Jimmy Chen

      Reading the article makes him sound like a mean jerk but watching the video gives a completely different impression to me.

  • GNexusPhone5

    Eric Jerk