Lawsuit against Apple’s Passbook is Lodsys redux

By , Oct 2, 2012

Apple is again in the sights of a company with patents and an itchy trigger finger. The iPhone’s Passbook feature, which allows consumers to store tickets, loyalty cards, coupons and such digitally, is the target of San Diego-based Ameranth. The company is seeking triple damages, claiming in the lawsuit that the Cupertino, Calif. technology giant willfully infringed on Ameranth patents on wireless mobile payments.

The company has already sued the likes of Hilton, Marriott and Ticketmaster and gotten 14 other companies to ink licensing pacts. TechCrunch spoke to the CEO of one of the companies who’d rather pay than suffer some long drawn-out legal fight. The interview is enough to send cold shivers up Apple developers who survived the 2011 patent uproar from Lodsys

In an interview, SubtleData founder Richard Bagdonas, warns that the lawsuit could expand from just Apple to target every developer connected to the Passbook feature. In other words, Passbook devs had better immunize themselves by paying financial homage to Ameranth. As writer Darrell Etherington notes, SubtleData — which licenses Ameranth technology — also sub-licenses from the company and will financially benefit from developers who do sign on the dotted-line.

If this seems like deja vu all over again, you’re correct. In 2011, Lodsys came after every developer employing Apple’s in-app purchasing system. The company — which said its license with Apple didn’t protect developers — was roundly criticized as a patent troll. The firm’s desire to keep Apple’s horde of hungry lawyers leashed failed, of course. The iTunes creator essentially shredded any argument keeping it out of the fight.

To be fair, Ameranth isn’t a clone of Lodsys. For one, Apple has cited the firm’s patent as prior art in connection to the iPhone. For another, the company supposedly does produce more than lawsuits. According to Bagdonas, Ameranth sells wireless ordering systems to restaurants.

No one would be a stronger supporter of defending patent rights than Apple, which has waged a global battle against rivals, using its patents as an effective legal cudgel. However, this lawsuit against Passbook and the intimated threats against all Passbook developers is one we think everyone — even Samsung — hopes will go away.

  • Share:
  • Follow:
  • http://twitter.com/xXJeanmarchpXx JeanMarc

    Here we go again

  • ic0dex

    It’s funny how no one ever hears of these companies but yet they all hold these patents. Then they wait for a company to creat a similar product and once it’s out on the market they hit them with a big law suit.

    • goofygreek

      I never heard of siri. Only heard of it when apple introduced it, and then i find out it already existed. So, its very possible to not hear of these companies b/c they are very small, and there is only a billion other companies that may do the same thing.

      • http://twitter.com/grantster5405 Grant Lawrence

        Nuance was the company responsible for Siri, and they are much much more than just a small company…

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002136300838 Michael Hulet

        For the record, a guy in Finland who started a business called Siri Inc. made Siri, and it was a very small company… They just used Nuance’s voice recognition engine

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=604885391 Richard Borkovec

      Ameranth “has been mentioned as a market/technology leader in numerous prestigious
      publications such as the Wall Street Journal, New York Times, Chicago
      Sun Times, USA Today, Business Week, TIME, CNN-fn, US News & World
      Report.” They’ve been around since at least 1998, they’ve won 12 different technology awards, and are, in part, funded by Microsoft. So the crap about “no one” hearing of these companies is total BS. It’s called research. You’d be surprised how many companies you actually deal with on a daily basis.

  • f5faith

    Apple should just buyout the Lodsys group and reduce every single employee into cleaning staff~ then hand out punishments for every speck of dust particles found in Apple HQ

    • seyss

      It wont help. More companies like Lodsys/Ameranth will keep showing up and causing panic until the patent system is fixed.

  • inc188

    fcking trolls…. gotta hate them