The iDevices HomeKit Wall Switch fixes one of the crucial issue with many smart homes. Not only does it fix a glaring issue, it comes with enough bells and whistles to make it the best HomeKit wall switch on the market.

HomeKit makes it effortless to control your home. From lights, locks, fans, speakers, and much more. All HomeKit devices play well with one another, so no matter the product you get, you know it will be compatible with your smart home.

The problem with a HomeKit home

The most popular thing for smart home adopters is lights. They are something basic that everyone uses. The problem is, most people use systems like Lutron or Philips Hue. They (for the most part) cannot be controlled by switches in your house. While those systems are great, it makes it more difficult for you to control your lights without using your devices or Siri. That means you must always have a device present.

Obviously, that isn’t ideal for you 100% of the time, or your guests.

Yes, those manufacturers do produce their own switches, which may or not be HomeKit capable. They are still quite expensive, limited in their functions, and can only control their products.

Even if you did opt to use something like the Hue dimmer switch, that would leave your existing wall switches useless. If you turn them off, your smart lights will no longer function. It’s for that reason I see many smart homes with tape over their wall switches.

The solution

To solve this, it seems pretty straightforward. You need to effectively take your wall switches, and turn them into HomeKit devices that can control any other HomeKit gear in your house.

Clearly, that is what the iDevices wall switch aims to do.

What is it?

The iDevices Wall Switch is a replacement receptacle for your existing switches. This is not like the majority of smart outlets on the market that plug in to the wall. You actually have to do some wiring, which immediately can scare people off.

The device itself is a little on the large size, making it a bit of a tight fit if you have an overly crowded electrical box. Unfortunately, that isn’t something you may be aware of until you take your existing switch out.

Installation

The installation of the iDevices switch is fairly easy to do. If you consider yourself fairly handy. You don’t have to do anything different than any other light switch, so it’s a pretty straightforward job that many people can tackle themselves. If you are nervous, it is never a bad idea to have a professional come out and handle it for you. Remember, always turn off the break before doing any electrical work!

Why is it better?

There are several HomeKit switches on the market. So what sets the iDevices one apart? There are many unique aspects to it. To start, the LED nightlight in the center of the switch is also HomeKit capable. That means you easily change the color and brightness to customize it. They also paid attention to design. If you have this mounted in your wall, how do you access the HomeKit code printed on the side? Easy. They have a pull out tab on the top that also has the code, so you can easily access it at any time.

It is also WiFi-connected instead of just Bluetooth. That means you don’t have to be in proximity, or have a HomeKit hub nearby to make it work. The WiFi also allows it to work with other digital assistants like Amazon Alexa.

One of the biggest selling points, is that it also works in multi-switch setups. For instance, say you have a hallway light. You have one switch on one end of the hallway, and another switch at the other. You need a three-pole switch to make that happen, and a four-pole switch if you have another switch involved. Many other HomeKit switches will not work in that situation, but the iDevices one does. That is a big deal for those in larger homes.

Automation

The automation aspect is really where HomeKit shines. There are a few common scenarios that work well with a HomeKit switch. Here are a couple that I personally utilized these switches for.

Hallway

In the hallway, we have a switch downstairs, and upstairs. The lights are odd bulbs that I can’t replace with Hue. Most other HomeKit switches won’t work because it is a three-pole setup. What I did was replace a switch with the HomeKit one. Now I can control them from my phone, and schedule them. What was more useful though, was the addition of a motion sensor. We covered the Eve motion sensor in the past, and it worked well for this.

Now, when we come down the stairs, at night, the hallway lights come on. It’s fantastic because I can signify only certain hours, and turn non-HomeKit lights into schedulable, automated, smart lights.

Living Room

In my living room, we’ve got lots going on. Again, lights plugged into HomeKit outlets, like the one from iDevices, as well as track lights up above. I also have an exterior door, right into the living room we use frequently.

In this situation, I used the geofencing feature of HomeKit to automatically turn the lights on when I arrive, and turn off when the last person leaves. Similar to the bedroom, it also allows me to tie them all together, regardless of how they are connected, and even put them on a motion sensor.

Bedroom

In the bedroom, we have a ceiling mounted light. The switch controls that ceiling light, as well as one of the outlets. The issues we had was that the Hue lights would not reach here reliably from where our hub was located downstairs. We also had more than one light to plug into the wall that wasn’t controlled by the switch. Lastly, we weren’t able to turn them on and off from bed. Just the one on the bedside table, but that was actually controlled by the wall switch. So if we turned it off by hand, the switch would no longer control it, or if the switch was off, it wouldn’t turn on at all.

To handle this, I installed the iDevices wall switch, and set up a few simple rules. First, when the switch is turned on, also turn on the HomeKit outlet with our extra lamp. When it turns off, do it in reverse. Now with one button press, everything is synced up together. Or I can use Siri from bed, and control just the switch, just the outlet, etc.

A fun other trick too, was to have my lights automatically come on in the mornings to help me get up for work.

iOS 11 additionally improves things, because there are timers. So when I turn the light on from the switch, it automatically turns off in thirty minutes.

Night light

Though many smart switches have integrated a nightlight, the iDevices wall switch is the only one with a smart nightlight. The miniature LED positioned in the center of the switch can not only change color, but can be completely scheduled and automated. It actually shows up in HomeKit apps as a separate device. This has several practical uses.

In a bathroom, you can have an iDevices wall switch, and a motion sensor. During the day, when you walk in, the motion sensor tells the switch to turn the lights on. Doing the night however, the motion sensor tells the switch to instead turn the nightlight brightness up to 100% and a warm white, then when you leave go back down to a dim blue glow.

In the bedroom, use it as bedtime alarm for your kids. Red light means they must stay in bed, and green means they are allowed to get out. You can schedule it to go along with their bedtimes, and even have separate schedules for weekends.

For me, I use it to determine how late I’m running for work in the morning. It is easier for me to see a color rather than grabbing my phone and turning it on to see how much time I have left before I need to get up. With the nightlight, I have it change from green, t0 yellow, to orange, and then to red on workdays based on the time. With red meaning “Get out of bed now!”

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Nightlight is HomeKit capable
  • HomeKit, Alexa, and Google Home support
  • Match your home design with any faceplate
  • Easy access to HomeKit home
  • 3 and 4 pole support
  • iOS 11 makes it even better with new controls
  • Wi-Fi is more reliable than Bluetooth
  • Clean, simple design
  • Cheaper for rooms with many lights

Cons

  • Must provide your own faceplate
  • More expensive than other options

Wrap Up

I feel like light switches aren’t the most exciting thing. If you are to have a HomeKit home, they can not only be affordable, but necessary. Many rooms have several lights that are more expensive to replace than a single switch, and other lights can’t be replaced at all.

If you don’t use Alexa, Google Home, the nightlight, or three or four-pole setups, you most likely don’t need to splurge on the iDevices wall switch, and may be better suited for the Eve. However if any of those apply to you, then the iDevices offering is the best choice you can make.

You can buy the iDevices Wall Switch for $99.

  • Corey Besmer

    Dang, I was so excited to see some competitors to Luttron’s offerings but got a serious case of sticker shock on seeing that $99 price. It does look a lot more “normal” than Luttron’s at least.

  • Chris Ryan

    Respectfully , Andrew, you have not done your research regarding the Lutron switches…they have ones with nightlights, they are home kit compatable, and can be used to control other home kit devices such as philips hue…they cost less and imho, look nicer. They are normal sized and fit easily into a standard receptacle box, and can be used to control 3 way or 4 way switches as well…And the pico remotes can be used to create a “switch” anywhere without additional wiring.

    • eigenlaut

      also – Philips Hue has not 1 but 2 switches to interact with your hue lights called “Hue Tap” and “Hue Switch”

      • Hi eigenlaut, so the difference between the Hue’s offerings and the iDevices switch, is that the Hue ones only work with Hue lights, and you still can’t use your existent lights. So if you have built in track lighting, or a mounted ceiling light in the bedroom, you can’t use your wall switch, and need to almost tape it off so you (or others) don’t accidentally hit it. The second thing is if you have lights that you can’t replace like the track lightning, you can’t control them at all with Hue. Lastly, other HomeKit devices like fans or smart outlets can’t be controlled via wall switch. So for sure! If you have just Hue lights and don’t mind neglecting the wall switches you have, the Hue switches are great! In fact I use one in my downstairs bathroom! But for most else, a HomeKit wall switch is the way to go.

      • Andrew O’Hara

        Hi eigenlaut, so the difference between the Hue’s offerings and the iDevices switch, is that the Hue ones only work with Hue lights, and you still can’t use your existent lights. So if you have built in track lighting, or a mounted ceiling light in the bedroom, you can’t use your wall switch, and need to almost tape it off so you (or others) don’t accidentally hit it. The second thing is if you have lights that you can’t replace like the track lightning, you can’t control them at all with Hue. Lastly, other HomeKit devices like fans or smart outlets can’t be controlled via wall switch. So for sure! If you have just Hue lights and don’t mind neglecting the wall switches you have, the Hue switches are great! In fact I use one in my downstairs bathroom! But for most else, a HomeKit wall switch is the way to go.

    • Hi Chris!
      Actually, I tested the Lutron system the day they launched! I’m very familiar with their setup!

      The big difference is that Lutron requires the bridge. That can partially slow down the response time, and increase the cost if you only need a single switch. Many people also go for accessories that don’t require a bridge at all.

      Then there is the issue of how they actually connect. The Lutron switches connect over RF, which requires all switches are within a 30ft range of the bridge, or within another accessory. While I was testing, this worked well, but when I had to daisy chain them together to get to remote parts of my house, the signal wouldn’t always go through. I notice a similar thing with the Hue bulbs when I use bulbs as repeaters to extend the range. The iDevices switches are a bit pricier because they just build WiFi in directly so you can place them anywhere you have WiFi and get 100% reliable connections.

      Lastly, I prefer the looks of iDevices to Lutron. I like that I can get a faceplate to match my interior than being stuck with what they include. I know that looks are subjective, and some people many not care if they match or not, but its still something to consider.

      Don’t get me wrong, Lutron is great! They offer a rather affordable way to get many HomeKit accessories connected. I personally love their blinds! But for switches, I lean towards iDevices, even if they are pricier.

    • Andrew O’Hara

      Hi Chris!

      Actually, I tested the Lutron system the day they launched! I’m very familiar with their setup!

      The big difference is that Lutron requires the bridge. That can partially slow down the response time, and increase the cost if you only need a single switch. Many people also go for accessories that don’t require a bridge at all.

      Then there is the issue of how they actually connect. The Lutron switches connect over RF, which requires all switches are within a 30ft range of the bridge, or within another accessory. While I was testing, this worked well, but when I had to daisy chain them together to get to remote parts of my house, the signal wouldn’t always go through. I notice a similar thing with the Hue bulbs when I use bulbs as repeaters to extend the range. The iDevices switches are a bit pricier because they just build WiFi in directly so you can place them anywhere you have WiFi and get 100% reliable connections.

      Lastly, I prefer the looks of iDevices to Lutron. I like that I can get a faceplate to match my interior than being stuck with what they include. I know that looks are subjective, and some people many not care if they match or not, but its still something to consider.

      Don’t get me wrong, Lutron is great! They offer a rather affordable way to get many HomeKit accessories connected. I personally love their blinds! But for switches, I lean towards iDevices, even if they are pricier.

      • Mike

        $50 Smartthings Hub
        $35-40 GE Light Switch

        While Homekit it alright its not the best. It’s good for simple devices but in the future if you want to add more devices you have to make sure first it works with Homekit. On the other hand if you end up going with Wink2 or Smartthings you will have a way bigger option of what you can use. Does Homekit require an Apple TV to control your devices away from home?

      • Andrew O’Hara

        A few things to touch on!
        Yes. Absolutely you can do that with SmartThings. However, there are many reasons people choose HomeKit over other platforms.

        The biggest reasons include:
        -Security
        -Reliability
        -Ease of use
        -100% compatibility

        With other home automation networks, you need to make sure they work with specific hubs and protocols. Anything labeled HomeKit works with all other HomeKit accessories and apps.

        They are also dead simple to set up and very reliable. The security is probably the reason many people choose it over others. Not too long ago The Verge put out a piece on how researchers uncovered a litany of security flaws in SmartThings. For something controlling my home, security is the most important. Each HomeKit accessory on the market now has a special chip purchased from Apple, then is sent to Apple for further compliance testing to be sure it is up to their quality.

        Unfortunately, all those good qualities do come with some downsides. Such as the higher cost associated with them, and support for certain genres of devices. Luckily, costs have been coming down significantly as Apple adopts new ways to authenticate devices, and new device categories have been added every year since launch.

        For most people, HomeKit is the safest, easiest, and most approachable home automation platform.

        To control devices remotely, especially bluetooth ones, you need some sort of hub. With SmartThings, you need a hub to give remote access, and HomeKit is the same. Except they make it easier by allowing you to use any Apple TV or iPad as the hub and not requiring a new purchase if you already have them.

        Hope that helps!

    • adobe3dfx3

      Chris, which Lutron Caseta switch that has a nighlight that is compatible with Apple Homekit? Can you direct me to a link?

  • Kira Fancy

    Thanks, that was quite informative review.