Beijing court orders iPhone 6 sales ban over patent infringement, Apple to appeal ruling

By , Jun 17, 2016

iPhone 6 Plus (hand 001)

Apple just hit yet another roadblock in China with news that the Beijing Intellectual Property Office (BJIPO) has ordered the company to halt sales of the iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus on the grounds that the Apple handset copied the design of the 100C smartphone, which is being produced by Shenzhen Baili, one of China’s phone vendors.

Apple has confirmed that it will challenge the sales ban by appealing to the Beijing Higher People’s Court and the Supreme People’s Court.

The iPhone models in question infringe on Shenzhen Baili’s patent for exterior design for its 100C smartphone, the Beijing Intellectual Property Bureau wrote in a statement on its website dated May 19.

“While the decision covers only Beijing, future lawsuits against Apple could take the case as a precedent, potentially influencing the outcomes of litigation elsewhere in China,” reads the article.

The ruling only applies to the city of Beijing, home to 22 million people. It doesn’t help that, as the pictures clearly attest, the iPhone 6 does not resemble the Baili 100C at all.

Baili 100c

Apple officially commented through the mouth of its spokeswoman, Kristin Huguet, who said in a statement to media that the iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus as well as iPhone 6s, iPhone 6s Plus and iPhone SE models “are all available for sale today in China.”

“We appealed an administrative order from a regional patent tribunal in Beijing last month and as a result the order has been stayed pending review by the Beijing IP Court,” she added.

Curiously, The Wall Street Journal article covering the news cited a person familiar with the production plans as saying that Apple will “soon end production of both” the iPhone 6 and iPhone 6s models even though the company tends to keep past two iPhone generations on the market at reduced prices when introducing a brand new model.

Apple is increasingly facing opposition by the Chinese government, which recently shut down the iBooks Store and iTunes iMovies in the country. In addition, the Cupertino firm has lost the exclusive right to the “iPhone” trademark in China last month.

It will be interesting seeing whether Apple settles this one out of court or if it chooses to fight the ruling through the end.

Source: Bloomberg, The Wall Street JournalBJIPO

  • Share:
  • Follow:
  • Chindavon

    Is this a 2017 April Fools joke posted way too early?


    Taiwan is the real China!!

  • igorsky

    I think all these recent anti-Apple moves by China are meant to be punitive in response to Apple not opening up their code to them.

  • LOL

  • Shinonuke

    These guys are super smart. They see a product that they think they can sell, they copy and patent designs and implementations in their country. When the real product comes over, they sue. This is a good business strategy. Not an honorable one but still a good income generator.

    • igorsky

      What if the iPhone was your product? Would you be as complementary towards their “good business strategy”? Or would you think that they’re being sleazy scumbags?

      • Shinonuke

        It’s a good business strategy for them due to their culture of doing business. It is not my personality to have a dishonorable business strategy. Honest businessmen would never have come up with that kind of business strategy

    • Tommy

      Have you seen the Meizu Pro 6? They literally took the iPhone 7’s spyshot design and made it into their latest flagship. Not sure if they’ll sue Apple once Apple releases the 7.

      • Shinonuke

        You bet they will. These money hungry phony won’t wait for w chance to make a quick buck

  • Dave Kurt

    Looks more like the 2008’s iPhone 3… Talk about conceited obtrusion, damn!

  • Dave Kurt

    Better sue Apple 8 years ago, too. 😀

  • Charlie

    Well the one that’s banned is iPhone 6 and most Chinese wouldn’t get anything that weren’t the latest anyway

  • Adriano França

    which one is the iPhone, i can’t distinguish

  • Quilliv

    I believe it…

  • Nathan

    Dumb drones. Literally all drones to their government.

  • is it really true LOL>

  • ShadowBlader

    Really china? It doesn’t even come close to resemble an iPhone lol.

  • Alex Wilson

    Simple solution. Close down all manufacturing and supply chain providers for the iPhone. Same for any Mac production as well.

  • Alu Zeros

    Lol China is a joke, can’t invent anything on their own due to a corrupted govt

  • As usual, China and Chinese, no honor.