January 2007 iPhone introduction (Steve Jobs, multitouch patented slide)

“Boy, have we patented it!”, quipped Steve Jobs in wrapping up the segment of his January 2007 MacWorld Expo presentation dealing with the iPhone’s multi-touch user interface.

Months later, Jobs through the combination of sheer willpower, yelling and F-bombs would impose restrictions on early Android releases.

The goal was to prevent Google’s smartphone software from employing multitouch gestures on mobile devices that Apple had been researching for years. The strategy eventually failed, prompting Apple to launch proxy battles against Android backers such as HTC, Samsung and Motorola over prized iPhone inventions.

One guy was unimpressed, though: a California inventor has been claiming for years now that he holds a patent related to an essential iPhone feature. He’s not afraid to take the consumer electronics powerhouse to court in order to prove the infringement and seek a five percent cut of Apple’s US sales, Bloomberg reported Tuesday…

The Bloomberg article explains:

Apple Inc., the world’s most valuable technology company, faces a trial over claims by a California inventor that a patent he holds covers key features of the iPhone. Apple maintains the NetAirus Technologies LLC patent is invalid because the technology was known long before the company filed its patent.

NetAirus’s owner Richard L. Ditzik invented the 1997 patent application for a handheld device that combines computer and wireless-communications functions over both local and wide-area network.

He filed a lawsuit against Apple three and a half years ago, claiming Apple ripped off his invention which allows devices such as the iPhone to automatically switch between a Wi-Fi and a cellular network connection.

Apple argues its own Newton message pad preceded Richard’s invention.

The technology at issue was so well known at the time NetAirus filed its patent, that independent patent watchdogs have made NetAirus’s patent a poster child in the movement to limit the proliferation of facially invalid patents.

The case is limited to pre-iPhone 4s devices as the judge denied NetAirus’s motion to include later iPhone and iPad hardware in its complaint. Should Ditzik prevail, Apple will have to pay some damages.

If you ask Ditzik, a reasonable royalty rate would be something between three to five percent of Apple’s U.S. sales. Fortunately, the Judge has dismissed his proposal as an “improper expert opinion offered by a lay person”.

Bloomberg adds:

In May, Apple won a ruling that NetAirus can’t seek damages for alleged infringement that occurred before Oct. 8, 2012, when the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office issued a reexamination certificate that the judge agreed “substantially” changed the patent’s claims. The ruling narrows the potential damages to sales of iPhone 4 models after that date.

Speaking of inventors, here’s Jobs presenting the original iPhone’s patented multi-touch user interface.

Too bad Google’s former CEO Eric Schmidt, who at the time had a seat on Apple’s board, betrayed Jobs with Android, which marked the start of the Great Smartphone Patent Wars.

  • Flex

    Without even checking let me guess who wrote this article…. Christian?

    • Nate McKelvie

      Why?

    • iBanks

      You checked…

    • Jason Duong

      All he does is yap on about something that’s not even remotely related to the news other than the word ‘patent’.

      The first third of the the article isn’t even needed. Remove that, and the news still gets acrossed.

      Then the last bit of the article is just useless crap to make this article look longer, it’s not even effing required.

      Where the hell did this guy get his journalism degree?

      The news was about a Cali guy’s patent lawsuit against apple. Nothing more.

      Yet somehow this Christian guy manages to weave in Google/Android, Android Smartphone vendors, Apple’s multi touch patent and Steve’s presentation of the iPhone capabilities.

      We want the news, not the bullsh*t.

  • CollegiateLad

    I think I’m suffering from litigation fatigue…

    These are the kinds of articles that you read and forget about them as fast as you read them.

    • AndroidDogHeatandSteelersFan

      Still interesting. But I wish more jailbreak new tweaks and reviews ! and progress on JB too!

      • AndroidDogHeatandSteelersFan

        BECAUSE I MISS… messages+

      • jocastro

        bitesms duhhhh 😛

      • jocastro

        yeah i downloadblog, its not like it used to be 🙁

  • jocastro

    10 bucks says apple will lol

  • chris125

    Good for him. Apple loves to sue everyone so if they are wrongfully using his patented tech he deserves to get $$ for it. Will see how this plays out.

  • Truffol

    “The technology at issue was so well known at the time NetAirus filed its patent” This can give you a sense of how broken our patent system is. Is Apple about to get a taste of its own medicine?

  • Chuck Finley

    So when Apple sue the hell out of everybody it’s just “Apple totally defending their innovations” whereas when if anyone sues Apple they’re another dirty patent troll?

    Wow. Your fanboy is showing. What a pile of rubbish.

  • Ted Forbes

    Goodluck guy.

  • Darshir Brewington

    ARE
    YOU A BUSINESS ENTREPRENEUR OR INVENTER? DO YOU HAVE THE NEXT GENIUS IDEA FOR YOUR OWN MILLIONAIRE DOLLAR PRODUCT OR SERVICE?

    A NEW TRAILBLAZING TELEVISION SERIES IS CURRENTLY SEEKING INDIVIDUALS WITHIN THE LOS
    ANGELES AREA AND SURROUNDING AREAS WITH REVOLUATIONARY, CUTTING-EDGE BUSINESS
    IDEAS AND INVENTIONS. WE ARE LOOKING FOR THE NEXT BIG THING THAT WOULD BE
    CONSIDERED NOTHING LESS THAN “GENIUS!”

    WE ARE IMMEDIATELY CASTING THOSE WHO ARE READY TO GET THEIR GROUNDBREAKING COMPANY
    OR INNOVATIVE PRODUCT OFF THE GROUND WITH OUR EXPERT ASSISTANCE AND EXPOSURE!
    RATHER YOUR PRODUCT/BUSINESS IS ALREADY ESTABLISHED OR YOU ARE JUST STARTING
    YOUR ENTREPENEURIAL JOURNEY, WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU!!!!

    IF THIS IS YOU OR YOUR COMPANY PLEASE EMAIL
    THATSGENIUSCASTING@GMAIL.COM WITH YOUR NAME, PHOTOGRAPH, CONTACT INFO (E-MAIL
    AND TELEPHONE), COMPANY NAME, DESCRIPTION OF YOUR
    COMPANY/PRODUCT/SERVICE/INVENTION, AND WEBSITE LINK OR PRODUCT/INVENTION PHOTOS.