The misunderstood iPhone 5c

By , Sep 11, 2013

pink iPhone 5c pink background

There weren’t many surprises left yesterday during Apple’s iPhone event where not one, but two devices were unveiled. There was of course the iPhone 5s, the new flagship device, and also the iPhone 5c, the rumored inexpensive iPhone aimed at emerging markets and first time smartphone buyers. At least that’s what we all believed.

If we all knew early on what the iPhone 5c was going to look like, there was something we were not certain about: the pricing. With an estimated unsubsidized price tag of $450, the iPhone 5c was supposed to hit the sweet spot. It was not Samsung-cheap, but it was not iPhone-expensive either, making it the defacto budget iPhone Wall Street had been pushing for.

Wall Street had actually brainwashed us to believe that a cheaper iPhone was what Apple needed in markets where the company isn’t doing as well as it should, such as China, and other parts of Asia, Russia, etc.

Whether Wall Street is right or not doesn’t matter because, as always, Apple didn’t let the money men dictate the company what to do. As always, Apple went Apple’s way and unveiled a device that is everything but affordable. It sure is $100 less than the top of the line iPhone 5s, but starting at $549 off contract, the iPhone 5c is still $100 more expensive than our wildest expectations.

So what happened?

The cheap iPhone that was never meant to be cheap

So much for cheap iPhone.” “$549 is not cheap.” These are some of the recurring comments I could see around the web, and while I was surprised about the price tag too, I had to quickly reframe my thoughts to actually see the bigger picture behind the price.

The thing is, Apple never said they would release a budget iPhone. Again, we’ve been brainwashed to believe that they would, which led to the massive disappointment. I’ll admit that we at iDB, have been guilty of fueling the idea of a budget iPhone too, just like about every media outlet out there. I take full responsibility for that. But it’s not about what media think will happen, it’s about what actually happens.

And what happened is that Apple took us by surprise. Being mad at Apple for not releasing a product they never planned to release in the first place is nonsense. Again, they never said anything about a budget iPhone to begin with, so the iPhone 5c should not be seen as a failed budget iPhone, but rather as a wonderful marketing coup.

A new phone to serve even more customers

The business has become so large that this year, we’re going to replace the iPhone 5. This will allow us to serve even more customers.” This is how Tim Cook started his introduction of the iPhone 5c before having Phil Schiller get on stage to do the full presentation.

I think the biggest mistake one can make when thinking about the iPhone 5c is to see it as “just an iPhone 5 with a polycarbonate rear plate.” Although tech specs might make it sound like it is, the marketing message will completely overwrite that.

The iPhone 5c is not last year’s iPhone in a plastic shell. The iPhone 5c is this year’s iPhone, starting $100 lower.

Do you get the difference? Apple is not marketing last year’s device anymore. It’s selling a brand new device that will become a brand of its own, instead of always being referred to as last year’s device. If you can’t wrap your head around the marketing concept here, try to make the parallel with the MacBook and the MacBook Pro. The MacBook is the iPhone 5c, and the MacBook Pro is the iPhone 5s. It’s exactly the same dynamic going on here.

With Apple’s marketing machine carefully oiled, I believe the iPhone 5c will sell by the truckload. If people like you and me know the technical differences between the iPhone 5 and the iPhone 5c, I can guarantee that 99% of people out there have no idea, and more importantly, they don’t care. What they care about is having this year’s new iPhone, without spending too much. Starting at $99 with a two year contract, the iPhone 5c is a great deal for people who don’t care about having the best possible iPhone, or simply for people who don’t want to spend too much on a phone.

The takeaway

If you’re still thinking the iPhone 5c is too expensive, you must get this “budget iPhone” idea out of your head. The iPhone 5c is not a budget iPhone and it was never meant to be.

If you’re disappointed because you believe the iPhone 5c is last year’s iPhone in a plastic rear casing, you must understand that it doesn’t matter because the iPhone 5c is not for you to begin with.

If you’re still thinking Apple failed with the iPhone 5c, you must get passed your emotions and realize that the iPhone 5c is a marketing strategy, not a revolutionary device in the technical sense.

  • Share:
  • Follow:
  • blastingbigairs

    Like I’ve been saying all along, Apple doesn’t do cheap and never will. If you are wanting cheap, then get Apple out of your noodle.

  • Jerwyn Feria

    So am I the only one with fat fingers accustomed to all the tiny screens ;) . Love them tiny screens. I also love them four inch screens. I am satisfied from what they had offered with the 5cs lines, but that #GOLDIPHONEMUSTHAVETHO!!!!

  • Jerwyn Feria

    So I dunno what is everyone’s deal. When the iPhone 5 came out last year, they decreased the price of the iPhone 4S down by $100 without modifying the product in any form. So now that they have released an iPhone 5s which is the upgrade to the iPhone 5 and released another line equivalent or maybe even a little better for $100 less. I don’t expect much more from apple because I follow the thought that they had made something that “feels familiar and yet, it’s new at the same time” Jony Ive (iPhone 5c intro video 4:10). Not as a brained washed dummy but a person that had accepted that fact.

  • vs511

    iPhone 5c is going to be an utter failure.

  • idevice_lover

    i bought the ipod, ipod nano, ipad, iphone, imac, macbook pro.. but actually this release a bit of disappointment for me. Usually every release, I update any of my iDevices, but this time, as in really this time, I am not doing it… I had it once enough when I updated my iPad 3 to the iPad 4. But this time round, it is not happening.. looks like Apple is the one that forcing us, the gadget freak customer, to update only once every two year, no longer a once a year upgrade.

  • Kristen Vacketta

    “If you’re disappointed,… you must understand that it doesn’t matter because the iPhone 5c is not for you to begin with.”

    Exactly. There are products, and there are demographics for them, and if you don’t like it then you probably weren’t in the demographic.

  • Marlber Cruz

    This is ridiculous! The only real new product apple has is the 5S. All
    that the 5C is a cheaply made version of the regular 5. Apple slapped a
    cheaper, colored back case, kept it all at the same relative price, and
    then have the gall to call it a “new” phone?! I guess their banking on
    people having more common sense then money. But please tell you guys at
    iDB can see this ruse for what it is? Not innovation, just a sad
    marketing attempt. This is just sad…

  • Palmer Paul

    Its actually MORE EXPENSIVE if you think about it. Let’s say Apple followed their previous marketing plan, where the previous year’s iPhone drops down to the mid-priced ($100 on contract) iPhone, the iPhone from two years ago becomes the cheap iPhone ($0 on contract), and the new iPhone is their flagship device (at $200 on contract). Following this model, the iPhone 5 would become the $100 device. This year however, they introduced the iPhone 5c, which has now replaced the iPhone 5 as the $100 device. Now let us look at the iPhone 5c. Despite what Sebastien said, the phone is still an iPhone 5 in terms of hardware. In fact that only difference between the two is the plastic casing of the 5c compared to the glass and metal casing of the 5. Now think about it…you are paying the same money for the 5c that you would be paying for the 5 (had they not introduced the 5c), however you are getting the same phone (from a technology standpoint) made out of cheaper materials. Therefore, Apple’s production costs go down (and you are getting a worse made product), yet they are still charging the same price for the product. Its like buying a half-gallon of orange juice for $3.50 and then suddenly, the orange juice is only 57oz., yet it still costs $3.50.