Google prematurely posts bad Q3 earnings, stock plunges

By , Oct 18, 2012

A strange thing has just happened: Google has posted its third-quarter earnings prematurely, giving Wall Street analysts and investors a pause as the company missed expectations substantially. Compared to Google’s stellar results in past few quarters, largely driven by soaring sales of ad slots and Apps hosted solutions for businesses, the September quarter saw the search giant stumble a bit.

The Mountain View, California-headquartered company reported a huge 20 percent dive in net income to $2.18 billion (operating income was $3.26 billion). Net revenue was $11.3 billion versus the $11.9 billion that investors had been expecting. Google earned $9.03 a share versus an analysts’ estimate of $10.65, a huge disappointment  analysts had expected, on average.

Doesn’t look good at all. I guess that $12.5 billion acquisition of unprofitable handset maker Motorola Mobility has really ‘paid off’, so to speak…

First, the earnings.

For a three-month period ending September 30, Google reported $45.7 million in cash – which includes the money in bank, but also cash equivalents and various short-term marketable securities.

Google’s Motorola subsidiary posted an operating loss in the second quarter so Google in August trimmed the fat by letting go one-fifth of Motorola’s global workforce. For the third quarter, Motorola raked in $2.58 billion in revenue but reported a $527 million operating loss: $505 million from the mobile biz and $22 million from Motorola’s home business.

Google noted as much in the filing:

GAAP operating loss for Motorola was $527 million ($505 million for the mobile segment and $22 million for the home segment), or -20% of Motorola revenues in the third quarter of 2012. Non-GAAP operating loss for Motorola in the third quarter of 2012 was $151 million, or -6% of Motorola revenues.

Motorola last month unveiled the new Droid Razr lineup, including the Droid Razr HD depicted in a promo clip below.

As for today’s blunder, Reuters reports that Google’s “surprise announcement” stunned investors who had been bracing themselves for an earnings release after the market close, as is customary.

The move rattled big boys on Wall Street, who punished shares which lost nine percent to $687.30.

Google Inc stunned Wall Street on Thursday with a significant miss on both revenue and earnings, wiping 9 percent off the market value of the Internet search and advertising leader.

The Wall Street Journal first reported of Google’s ill-timed announcement:

 The unexpected release, via a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission, triggered a selloff in Google shares. Shares dropped about 9% before trading was suspended. The results missed expectations and the company released its results several hours earlier than expected.

It wasn’t Google’s finest moment.


Graphics via Reuters Business.

The full filing was meant to be approved by the CEO, but it leaked:

The filing provided Google’s financials for the quarter, but was obviously released prematurely, as it included near the top “PENDING LARRY QUOTE” a reference to Google CEO Larry Page.

Bloomberg reports that Google has blamed financial printing company RR Donnelley for sending its earnings to the SEC incomplete and premature:

Earlier this morning RR Donnelley, financial printer, informed us they filed our draft 8K earnings statement w/o authorization.

That has got to be a very expensive screw up.

Pretty sure a few heads will roll today in Mountain View, California.

The company will officially announce earnings later today at 4:30pm Eastern / 1:30 Pacific (UPDATE: Google posted Q3 earnings).

I’m still puzzled as to how a company of Google’s size can afford such a misstep to release bad news prematurely.

It was inadvertent, or was it?

Did Google do this purposefully?

Just what was it hoping to achieve?

  • Share:
  • Follow:
  • http://www.facebook.com/joe.jonsen Joe Jonsen

    cause android suuuuuucks

  • http://twitter.com/J_Walker75 The Pied Piper

    If they can’t do something as simple as this, why would i invest my time/money in them?? Is the question that should be asked.

    • Anirudh B

      You realize Google wasn’t responsible, it was R.R. Donnelly that messed up?

  • Lordthree

    Another google ‘beta’

    • Mario.villegas90

      No maybe just like siri beta

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000027514739 Will Fancher

        The difference is that Google’s beta projects never get released.

  • VATekMan

    It’s funny how people are not upset about Google for not making money, just for not making as much as they would have thought. The same thing has happened before with apple and most other major companies. They make a lot of money, just not as much as the analysts predicted. So it is not a fault of the company, it is the analysts who “guessed” wrong about how good a company would do. Oh well.