Apple kills cross-promotions to protect the legitimacy of App Store charts?

By , Oct 1, 2012

It was reported that some users earlier this morning were faced with an endless loop preventing downloads because Apple updated the App Store terms and conditions. The company has quickly resolved the hiccup, but now another interesting change in terms indicates Apple could be clamping on apps which promote titles from a different developer…

PocketGamer spotted a slight change in the new Terms & Conditions, now specifically saying that “apps that display apps other than your own for purchase or promotion in a manner similar to or confusing with the App Store will be rejected”.

The publication speculates that Apple’s tightening of the terms could indicate a change in direction, where Apple would flatly reject any app that advertises other people’s apps.

The wording is typically vague, but clause 2.25 appears to give Apple carte blanche to put any app that promotes titles from a different developer out of action.

At the moment, we understand Apple’s likely prime targets are pure app promotion services, such as (but not necessarily including) FreeAppADay, AppoDay, AppGratis, Daily App Dream and AppShopper, amongst others.

Some people think the decision spells trouble on certain apps that rely on cross-promotions as high traffic enables ad-funded free apps. Cross-promotions can also artificially boost download count and affect the app’s rankings in the App Store so Apple could be interested to simply protect the legitimacy of the App Store charts here.

Be that as it may, I totally understand Apple’s position and support their decision, although the news doesn’t bode well for useful app discovery programs like AppShopper, an app I use on a daily basis.

Perhaps Apple is looking to kill both app promotion services and app discovery software such as AppShopper in one fell swoop because the company is about to introduce its own app discovery features.

Apple acquired discovery and recommendation engine Chomp in February, killing the Android version two months later as it vowed to tap the acquisition to make app discovery better.

So far, Apple only tweaked the search algorithm and the App Store layout so we have yet to see how the Chomp acquisition fits into a greater scheme.

The bug that prevented all App Store downloads appeared to have been limited to the U.S. App Store and was first reported by MacRumors.

Did you have trouble downloading apps yesterday?

And, do you support Apple’s decision to reject apps that advertise apps by other devs?

  • Share:
  • Follow:
  • http://www.facebook.com/abhinandh.ajay Abhinandh Ajay

    So there are people who read the Terms and Conditions !!

    • http://twitter.com/samerised 林毅弘

      my whole life was a lie! :rageface:

  • http://twitter.com/jmarsh5 Justin Marshall

    Unless Apple has something like AppShopper up its sleeve, I’m not sure this is good for them. After all, all those apps do are send people to the App Store where they spend money which apple gets a cut of. Isn’t that kind of the point?

    And the wording to me actually sounds like they mean advertising apps within apps literally, like in an iAd or something. Of course, I’m not the expert but that’s just what I originally thought when reading the article. If that was the case, it wouldn’t have been so bad.

  • @dongiuj

    I support Apple’s decision to reject apps that advertise apps, if they ever decided to do that.

    • Emre SÜMENGEN

      A/S/L plz. I like when you are sweet. Keep showing your tender side. Im prett tender and sweet myself

  • J M

    I use a few apps that operate free because of in-app ads. I would be very sad to see them either disappear, or become paid if this bars them from using in-app ads.

    I hope not included in this are the mechanisms where you can “watch” a video ad for another app to get that apps in-app money amount (things like Smoola for Smule, or minutes in VoIP type apps). Those are opt-in ads that I would imagine stay allowed since the customer is voluntarily clicking to view them…if not that would be another blow to those apps. Does apple get a cut of in-app purchases as well?

  • Carlos Briones

    I didn’t have problems downloading apps yesterday, but then again I haven’t downloaded any apps since Saturday lol. I think that their decision to reject apps such as those discovery apps was completely fine. If they’re introducing something like that there’s no reason to have other 3rd party apps that do the same or close to the same thing.

  • Falk M.

    Don’t touch AppTicker ಠ_ಠ

  • Kurt

    i’m sure appshopper and freeappaday are fine…i think apple is going to get rid of the annoying spamming you see in comments on an app that tell people they downloaded this app to get points in another app.

  • http://twitter.com/MoonbeamDev Moonbeam Development

    Here is our response to the change http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXCDXCP8Zsg