A German court has today ruled that Apple does not infringe upon patents held by Motorola which pertain to 3G/UMTS technology.

Motorola had claimed that Apple’s iPad and iPhone infringed upon patents held by the company. Judge Andreas Voss of the Mannheim Regional Court today ruled that Motorola did not present conclusive evidence of any infringement taking place and as such decided not to award an injunction.

The ruling relates to claim 9 of European Patent 1053613, entitled “Code and System for Generating a Complex Pseudonoise Sequence for Processing a Code Division Multiple Access [CDMA] Signal.” Snappy title indeed…

This is the latest in a long line of legal disputes for Apple, with Samsung also finding itself embroiled in a bitter row over patents all across the globe. This decision may have gone in Apple’s favor, though as we’ve seen in the past, that isn’t always the case. Apple had previously lost two similar spats in the same country related to GPRS technology and the use of push notifications.

Motorola Mobility is currently in the middle of a buyout by Google, and we are all watching eagerly to see how the situation progresses once Motorola is owned by the Google. Will things calm down, or will Google and Apple begin a very public legal battle that goes right to the heart of Android?

It’s like Judge Judy, isn’t it!?

[AppleInsider]

  • sn0wbaLL

    Alright! Woohoo!!

  • sn0wbaLL

    off the topic. one of the reasons why i bought an iphone 4S. I like to think of it as 4Steve. This may be the last product that has Steve Jobs’ perfection. Sure the iphone 5 and maybe even the iphone 6 will have Steve Jobs written all over them, but who’s to say that by the time they’re released, Tim Cook(great guy, but we’ve yet to see) wont change something. Maybe some of you also consider iPhone4Steve?:)